- April 5, 2009 at 10:54 am #447255
:(Hip replacement referral waiting lists.I will tell you my story and would be interested in any feedback, I’m at my wits end1
Tony Ryall, Minister of Health
I write to you in deep concern regarding my referral to see the Orthopediac Surgeon Waikato Hospital at the Tokoroa Hospital re a hip replacement.
I have now been waiting 6 months
October 2008 Dr C TOKOROA referred me to the TOKOROA HOSPITAL for an appointment to see the surgeon from Waikato.
The Doctors surgery checked again in November 2008 and I was not on the list.
I have been using a walking stick.
They checked again in December 2008, Tokoroa Hospital stated that my file had been put on hold (through misinformation.)
I inquired for crutches twice at Dr’s surgery and once at Tokoroa Hospital, getting no feedback, in December purchased my own pair.
I rang Drs surgery to check once more in February 2009 re appointment at the Tokoroa hospital , and I was told to ring and inquire at the Tokoroa Hospital myself, which I duly did.
Here I was given the run around for half an hour, but persevered , telling the person at the other end , I was on crutches and desperate!
On 11th February 2009 , 5 mths after the first refferal in October 2008, I receive the written confirmation that I have at long last been added to the Waikato DHP wait list ( but due to errors), from December 2008 not October 2008 and it will be 3 to 6 mths, which in my calculation will take it at the max to July 2009, which is almost a year from the original October 2008 refferal.
I must confess here that I feel like a piece of discarded flotsam that no one really cares a damn and this long wait worries me quite a lot, I have fallen once off my crutches, my knee is now painful, I have an old injury in the lower lumber region which I feel may worsen under the extra load strain. I have a horrible feeling I may end up in a wheel chair before seeing the surgeon and then there’s the long wait again for surgery.
I am a healthy 73yr old, have walked and cycled all my life, never had a car, am a Swedish massage Therapist working from a clinic in my home, now I can’t massage and I can’t leave my home, its all rather frustrating. I am prisoner in my own house, I am in constant pain, I can’t sit properly, I can’t bend to the toilet, my nights are hideous, I can’t take sleeping pills as I use the toilet 4 to 5 times a night, re bladder cancer, its all very depressing…
My quality of life has lessen considerably.
copies to: ,Hon Tony Ryall Minister of Health, MP Louise Upston ,MP Lindsay Tisch, Dr CaldwellTokoroa, ManagerTokoroa Hospital, Complaints Dept.,Waikato Hospital, Arthritis Foundation , Grey Power, Health&Disability Commissioner., 10/3/2009
From that letter i received one phne call from Waikato complaints, but no help
I have been on crutches for 7mths, never had anyone ask me how I manage, or or if I live alone, I have had no help or feedback except one phne call from Waikato, and one phne call from the Arthritis Foundation suggesting that I change my Dr…..a very very poor show….
continued……April 5, 2009 at 11:02 am #447257
well this is a game of perserverance, so one keeps up the fight! here is my next salvo!
Following on from my original letter 10/3/2009, to the Hon Tony Ryall, Waikato complaints Dept etc., re referral waiting lists to see Waikato Hospital Orthopaedic surgeons , I feel there is a murky corridor in the NZ health system where people over a certain age are shuffled to and fro as lost wraiths without any particular destination in sight…We trundle to the Dr just to get more pills, a few meaningless words and its the waiting game once more, one gets swamped with despondency and a feeling of helplessness. We get the sense that we are so much discarded flotsam, and there is not enough of the Doctors time for us, are we complaining unnecessarily? is this our lot to suffer?
We get fed the monotonous diet of it’s lack of funds, you’re on the list, unavailability etc., etc., and the ploy of the ‘ 3-6mths waiting list’ , designed solely as a pacifier to lull our anxiety. The 3-6mths so called ‘ LIST’ is the cruelest falsehood and slowly but surely it drifts into the realms of fantasy as time ticks on relentessly. And how many of the older folk would know about the points system you are judged by as to whether or not your condition is serious enough to be operated on in the near future? Not very accurate by all accounts.
So the journey plays out, one goes from a slight annoying limp, to a more obviously painful limp, then its the aid of a walking stick as one feels ones leg may just give way, and inability to sit without excruciating jagged pain…its popping mutiple painkillers till ones heart goes into arrhythmia, maybe a heart attack will finish the job….
so time ticks on and we wait, we the shadowy grey masses in our corridor of limbo…next its the crutches, hard on the shoulders but more manoeuverable than the walker, and the struggle goes on, going to the toilet is a major feat, a small task of putting ones nickers/shoes/slacks on become a battle to be won.There is always the gut sickening fear lurking in the back of one’s mind, I must not fall, one scutinizes the ground before every step this is urgent.The toilet bogey looms ominously, can I roll out of bed in time?, buggar that hurts, I must not stumble on the way to the loo, then there’s the struggle to sit on that damn seat, for me this is 4 to 5 times a night. Where sleep should be a healing blessing, for us it becomes a hideous nightmare, as every movement is pain accompanied by ominous crunchingl..Oh yes one can get onto heavier medication if one wishes to become a zombie caught in the twilight zone.
We cling to that faint ray of hope that faintly glimmers in the far distance, its that magical "LIST" and we believe what we are told by those that hold our fragile fate in their hands and thats our fatal mistake, never never take things for granted, find out for yourself. If I hadn’t perservered again and again, I would not be on the ‘LIST" but hey now I’m in that magical land of vanishing time! ie the 8 weeks that disappeared off my referral time.
Some even in their darkest moments of despair of anything ever happening and with the world of ongoing pain swallowing them into that dark place of no return, contemplate suicide…whilst waiting that unending wait for surgery. I have been told some real first hand horror stories of elderly persons and not so elderly, waiting for orthopaedic surgery, slowly losing their quality of life in urine smelling homes and shuffling around in continuous discomfort and pain, as they are shunted around the Health systems no mans land, I know this to be a sad fact.
The so called ‘points system appears to have some glaring faults letting many a needy person suffer the twilight of their lives in abject misery.Perhaps this is the name of the game? To cull out the weak & elderly so they will decease sooner than later and thus save money, a third world health system indeed..
In the same token I have first hand information from a person who worked at one of New Zealands main hospitals in the patient Orthopaedic referral clinic, and was told there is queue jumping, sometimes its a case of not what you know but who you know.
Another interesting fact in the shifting time zone of the’ referral list”, a friend of mine in Tokoroa who is not on crutches, has a crook knee, was referred by her Dr in February 2009 via Tokoroa Hospital, and oddly enough she has just had her appointment with the orthopaedic surgeon from Waikato at Tokoroa Hospital in March 2009? figure that one out!
The Health and Disablity Advocacy Foundation are not interested in ‘ waiting lists’ ,quote " we are the Nationwide Health and Disability Advocacy service not the Minister of Health. Unfortunately waiting list issues are not within the jurisdiction of our service.’ end of quote.
maybe some attention in this area, would be enlighening and beneficial, as it is all cause and effect, and it is far more efficient & cost effective to treat the cause than the effect.
Dire times indeed for the New Zealand’s forgotten folk languishing in a forgotten corridor of no time, when in 1991 the UNITED NATIONS GENEVA adopted, The United Nations Principles for Older Persons. http://www.un.org/NewLinks/older/99/principles.htm
One principal springs to mind here:
CARE: Older persons should have access to social and legal services and HEALTH CARE so that they can maintain an OPTIMUM LEVEL OF PHYSICAL, MENTAL AND EMOTIONAL WELLBEING.This should include respect for dignity, beliefs, needs and privacy
This list of UNITED NATIONS PRINCIPAL FOR THE OLDER PERSONS well being and rights should be put where it can be seen by the public in all Health, Care and Social Depts.,Surgeries , Rest Homes, Hospitals etc.,
as it would appear that most health care personal are totally oblivious to the existence of this UNITED NATIONS PRINCIPAL for older persons.
continued…..May 10, 2009 at 3:54 pm #447259
Update for those that are interested in the problem above….referral October 2008.
after much todo & kerfuffle one was given a appointment to see the Mr R Kyd, the Orthopaedic Surgeon from Waikato, on the 22nd April 2009, and his first comment after reviewing the xrays was:
‘ I don’t understand this, why has it taken so long?"
my sentiment exactly! hmmm now this sounded more promising to my ears…I was so emotionly up tight I had to choke back the tears.:cry:.someone at last, at damn long last was taking note of my condition
the following week I received a phne call from Waikato and the day after an appointment for pre admission checkup! on 14th May 2009 oh boy was I elated!:D after such a long painful battle, things were moving!!
But and a big but…..still no help,:roll: no one has been to see me in my home, no raised toilet seat which is a huge painful problem as anyone with hip problems will agree, at the moment I am using rolled up towels which isn’t really satifactory, this I really can’t comprehend, folk with severe pain with hip and knee problems NEED support and help BEFORE as well as after their operations… I have needed this special seat for 6 mths, so what goes on here? nothing it woud appear…..I have also changed my Dr.
I must say here that now at last I am under Waikato hospital ,I am hopeful and for the first time in a long long time feel confident this issue will now resolve itself more quickly …hmmm? time will tell.
So the saga continues………May 26, 2009 at 2:36 pm #447261
undefinedJune 4, 2009 at 9:54 pm #447263
lastest update to list referrals…well it was 5 weeks plus a day , to the day when I was seen by Mr R Kyd from Waikato at Tokoroa Hospital for orthopaedic assessment, to being scheduled for my total hip replacement with Dr Paul Wotherspoon and team on the 29th May 09…
So dawned Friday 29th, at 7.30 am, I was waiting down in the pre op rooms, nauseous & dry retching some bright spark the night before had seen fit to change my pain medication and given me TRAMADOL..warning leave it stricly alone, side effects, nausea, retching, wooziness, druggy dreams, halucinations…. the theatre nurse looking at me clutching my little plastic container, said ‘why on earth did they give you that and the maximun dose? I would not take it, too many side effects’, oh yeah now she tells me..:shock:
I was wheeled into the anteroom where the anesthetist from Thames had just arrived, a nice friendly fellow who told me it had been a cold drive over, we chatted as he got a lure in my arm, a couple more of the waiting surgical team came out of theatre, all scrubbed up and shining clean, with beaming smiles, their IDs dangling , 😀 their hair all nicely tucked under very colourul patterned cotton kerchiefs, I gave them some cheek, one informed me he didn’t want my discarded bone( I had signed to be a bone donor) as I had had bladder cancer, fair enough I said as I was wheeled into theatre… up on the far left side wall I saw all my hip xrays were highlighted & displayed and a distinct dark line had drawn on the xray of the right femur.(.lol 😆 cut here along the dotted line), joking…. I was busy looking around the theatre and making comments about the huge array of massive lights on the ceiling,above me , crikey what a barrage of lights! and that was it….next thing I remember was coming to being wheeled up to ward 16 and into room 11, that nice sneaky anesthetist had quite caught me unawares…..The tall dark and handsome Dr Paul Wotherspoon saw me the next day and looked quite satisfied with a job well done….
What can I say, I haven’t stopped smiling:D, that surgical team is simply the BEST!!!, what a fantastic job they have done, I am walking, no pain, no numbness, can bend my right knee, and best of all can go to the toilet without pain…they kept on asking what my pain threshold was. after being in agony for 7mths the ‘ pain ‘ I was feeling was nothing….I had a oxygen tubes in my nose which I got rid of pretty quick as it was making my nose raw inside, apart from that it was all smooth going, the staff at Ward 16 are just fabulous, caring in every sense of the word……..I was discharged on Wednesday 3rd June, after the op ( 6 days) and sent home with: some wooden gadgets to raise my bed 4 inches , fitted for crutches, a bath stool and a grabber…..I have nothing but praise for the Orthopaedic dept at Waikato, I was looked after and treated so well, all the bad times have faded away:cry:….but and a big BUT..in discussing my previous predicament with the occupational therapist there , we had a good long chat, about how help is needed BEFORE operations as well as after…..re my falling through a large hole in the system, he suggested some ‘people, meaning professionals’ don’t listen to you, that one should always stress most STRONGLY, how incapacited and how much in pain you are, and keep at it don’t give up, if you don’t get results you have the choice to a second opinion, I mean I was forced to use crutches for the last 7mths how obvious is that?
Well now I have a permenant smile on my face, my life has meaning once again, I am not dogged by vicious pain every moment, so I say a massive thank you to Mr R Kydd and his fantastic team of merrymen/women, I owe you guys my quality of life back and cannot begin to thank you enough..
Moral of story here is…keep asking..keep trying, don’t give up….you are precious and your quality of life is precious and you deserve that quality of life and care, it is your right as a citizen of New Zealand by World Human Rights Standards….
lol and wouldn’t you know it, still have not had anyone to my home for assessment re safety etc.,…of course I don’t need them now do I , but what a b******y rum do!
An English nurse in ward 16 said in England they are taught to help people BEFORE ops, re orthopaedic procedures, which would seem the logical and correct thing to do, so what’s gone so radically wrong here in NZ ? how many others are suffering needless pain and distress due to lack of the correct procedure being applied at the correct time for the orthopaedic patients wellbeing? All I can say is certain Health Depts should get their act together smartly !June 21, 2009 at 11:12 am #447265
😀 just a postscript for anyone that has followed this saga, just 2 weeks out from the hip replacement op and the wound was all healed, no pain, just utterly incredible, now three weeks, I am walking freely with only one crutch, have full mobility, no pain whatsoever, the most beautiful flat scar, if one can call it that as its almost vanished, I used black & blue cream from my Chiropractor on the bruising which has now all gone..amazing I haven’t stopped smiling yet:D a huge thank you to Mr R Kyd and Dr Paul Wotherspoon and surgical team at Waikato Hospital , they are simply the best!!!! I have a life again, thanks guys:D
Now 5 weeks out, amazing progress, using a cross trainer, lol just a couple minutes a day so far, most of the time around the house I don’t use a crutch, at 5 week checkup Dr P Wotherspoon was very pleased with the hips mobility and length, so it just gets better and better and I am still smiling….
http://twitter.com/Alienzone88October 7, 2009 at 11:12 am #447267
😯 Oh golly I just had to share this pearler! Last week I had a phone call, the voice on the other end said, wait for it…..this is the Occupatioal Therapist……and YOU have come to the……..TOP OF THE LIST!8) aha those ” LISTS” again..You says she, were refered in May. Well said I , my hip opp was in 29th MAY , and I don’t need you now..(remember this is now end of Sept.,) BUT I needed you very much 7 mths before the opp. when I was in so much pain……no comment or sympathy to that.
All I can say is God help those poor souls who can’t help themselves, this service STINKS!:?
Luckily I had a mighty good friend 😀 who helped me get the equipment I needed from Waikato Hospital before the opp. nothing from anyone else at all:(October 10, 2009 at 6:40 pm #447269
gayebelleMemberMember since: May 28, 2008
Alienzone88, I have only just come across this thread. What a time you have had. 😐 Glad you have finally got it sorted. Seems a terrible case of bad communication, (going by the postscript.)
I have done homecare for people in less horrific siituations than your prediciment, and you should have had at least this offered from your Dr. both prior and after your operation. 😉
So nice to see you have a happy face now, and able to lead a quality of life. You take care of yourself. 🙂
Southern Belle.November 27, 2009 at 5:42 pm #447271
Ho Ho Ho it looks like one has at long long last come to the top of yet another one of these seemingly USELESS WASTE OF TIME..’ LISTS!’…!
Last week I received a call from a totally disinterested female voice:shock:…IT…. said ‘I am calling from M P Louise Upton’s office…….the voice 😯 said ‘do you wish to follow on from your complaint???? complaint?…….. lady I said ,I had my hip operation 6 MONTHS AGO!! the complaint was well before that! I wish is that no one else has to go through the nightmare I did trying to get into the system, especially if they have no voice of their own:cry:……. so that was about the end of the conversation, was she interested? I think not, …did she take any notes of what I had just stated? damn sure she didn’t,… did she really care, I know she didn’t…..
Bye the way thank you Gay Belle for your kind words, it surely was an unbelievable situation, six months now since surgery and I still cannot grasp fully what a nightmare it was… BUT I am now 101% great, super, wonderful!
It was amazing success and I haven’t stopped smiling, lol except when I get a inane phne call 9 mths as above, after I had pleaded for help…Philistines!December 29, 2009 at 9:48 pm #447273
petal12MemberMember since: December 29, 2009
My advice would be to change your GP. If your Gp is proactive that helps immensely. Your Gp should be sending an urgent referral to the hospital stating your condition has worsened and you will be priotised again.January 30, 2010 at 12:10 pm #447275
I did thanks Petal 1 and its all done and dusted..101% success thanks to the fantastic surgical team at Waikato Hospital, they gave me my life back for which I am ever grateful!:DFebruary 13, 2010 at 8:55 pm #447277
lizzeyMemberMember since: October 19, 2009
I have just come across this thread and what a time you have had, but pleased to hear you are on the mend now Alienzone88. Just as well you changed your doctor. I can’t say enough about the medical team who helped my hubby but different circumstances for him though and unfortunlatly hubby passed away 3 yrs ago. Very lonely life without him now.March 2, 2010 at 8:39 am #447279
nirvanaMemberMember since: May 6, 2008
Best way to get replacement done in Christchurch go and see the the orthopod privately $120 then get referred to public system 6weeks and I had my hip replaced 4weeks post op marvellousJune 29, 2010 at 10:54 am #447281
Thank you Lizzy and Nirvana, well just had my yearly checkup and it was all good, the hip replacement was 101% successful, with full movement and what a difference it made to my quality of life, again my most grateful thanks to the surgical team, Mr Paul Wotherspoon and Co., you guys/girls are simply the best!:D…..I will just relate one thing that helped me..I had awful aching pain:( in my shin area few months out from op, I got someone to massage this for me which helped a lot..also later I could massage this area myself, this got rid of a bit of congestive tissue and did this on a regular basis with almond oil and around the scar area, the scar has virtually disappeared and my ankles a great!
Best of luck to anyone having this done8)March 30, 2011 at 11:25 am #447283
Well nearly 2years out now from when I had my operation for a total hip replacement,:D and not one single problem, healed like a dream ..no limp, actually sometimes I have to remind myself when bending down that I do indeed have an artificial hip……I had only one minor discomfort which was from what they had painted part of my um :shock:..bottom with, that drove me crazy for 3months,:cry: ( an allergy) to what ?) as I said a minor thing though damn annoying:( so once again I say my heartfelt thanks to that surgical team, to tall dark and handsome Mr Paul Wotherspoon and his merry band… you guys/girls are SIMPLY THE BEST!:D, my angels no less …with your combined skill and expertise you gave me my life back for which I am forever eternally grateful, no one that hasn’t suffered the ghastly continuous pain of a degenerate hip, can possibly know the absolute wonderful feeling of no pain and most of all mobility, so to anyone who has to have this op in the future, be not afraid or nervous, these guys and girls at Waikato Hospital are the TOPS!!!:D8)April 11, 2011 at 1:08 pm #447285
KiwiSueMemberMember since: September 4, 2006
Hi Alienzone88 – Have just read all your experiences with much interest. My husband – who is 79 on Wednesday – has just been diagnosed by our Dr that he needs to have a hip replacement and that we will have to have it done through Waikato Hospital. This is worrying the cr*p out of me (and my husband) so it was great to read your positive experience (about the op. I mean – not the delays). Sounds like you made an excellent recovery – I am therefore hopeful my husband who is a very fit, strong and healthy man will do likewise. Just hoping we won’t have to wait a year before he has the op. as we can’t afford the $15,000 quoted to do it privately.October 23, 2012 at 9:41 am #447287
ChudoMemberMember since: October 23, 2012
Greetings, I would like to thank alienzone88 for your story. My precious Mother is currently living your past predicament. I have watched my vital, fit and full of life Mother turn into a little old lady infront of my eyes. Despite navigating all the necessary avenues (the infinite loop of deferrals) is STILL not on a waiting list. I was thinking that it might help if I write to Mums doctor to emphasise the impact this is having on Mums quality of life. Any advise would be greatly appreciated.October 25, 2012 at 12:40 pm #447289
Arty23MemberMember since: June 29, 2008
I would also like to thank alienzone88 for your story. I have nearly reached the end of my tether with osteoarthritis in the spine. For past six months have been in agony, finally had x-ray which showed serious degeneration affecting two discs as well as bone spurs and ankalysing spondilitis (sp). Have waited for an appointment with neuro surgeon in ChCh but finally told they could not give me an appointment saying they were basing this decision on the letter sent to them by my G.P. I am absolutely devastated, can no longer stand or walk for more than five minutes and as I live on my own I don’t know where to turn. I do not have private health insurance. Does anyone know where I can turn to from here! Thank you for any feedback.October 25, 2012 at 11:31 pm #447291
MaebhMemberMember since: April 10, 2012
Go BACK to your GP and tell him what you just told us!
Yours is a quality of life issue and is affecting your ability to carry out your normal activities of daily living therefore must be actioned.
If the surgery is still a no-go, then you at the least need assessments by support services to see if you qualify for any assistance.
Has your GP been proactive in helping you to manage your pain or have you found any alternative ways of managing it?August 21, 2013 at 10:07 am #447293
Well guys and girls, here I am nearly 5yrs down the track from that horrific experience and its totally fantastic final outcome, never goes a day past that I don’t mentally thank tall dark and handsome Dr Wotherspoon and his merry team for my fantastic opp8)….I am now going on 78yrs old I have 15 grandchildren and 10 great grand children and many more to come.:o….I have 6 websites, am administrator of 2 facebook groups, I also travel NZ taking photos of olden day buildings etc.,before our history is lost in the mists of time…..I am a writer/poet/artist, I own a 2cv and we putter around the Nth IS, I do MARS research, downloading raw images off the Nasa site and putting them through photographic programmes to see what they are concealing under all those filters from the public……takes time but so so rewarding, just bought myself the best computer I could afford and monitor for my research work.. into organics etc., etc., so life it full on..heaps to do and still heaps to learn and research..moral of story..never give up..so blessings to my dear surgeon and his team……for my continued quality of life………:D
Just a postscript..just re reading my comment..re the bad irritation on side opposite bad hip..’my bottom’..I now realize someone had swabbed me with IODINE..!!!! it distinctly says NO IODINE..as I am allergic….damn.. that drove me nuts for months I tried about 8 different ointments..penny didn’t drop for a long while as to what had caused the bad irritation..1 point off!
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.